Section 31 is a mediocre action movie, even worse than Star Trek

There were now 14 Star Trek films over the past 50 years, however, the franchise has always had a reputation for cinematic struggle on the big screen. From cinematic sequels to the original show to the Kelvin Timeline reboot, Star Trek The question has always been how to turn a television series that prides itself on chatty diplomacy and meetings of scientific minds into a successful medium that warrants a sci-fi spectacle. He can Star Trek It still is Star Trek In such an environment? This week with arrival Article 31 on Paramount+Another question is boldly asked instead: What if A Star Trek The movie wasn’t interested in being Star Trek Film or even being a particularly interesting work?

Article 31 It took a long way from being one of Interesting first TV shows to Star TrekThe era of broadcasting is yet to come discoveryThe first season, before disappearing into the shadows and reappearing years later as a cinematic vehicle for Now Oscar winner Michelle Yeoha bumpy ride that felt intense throughout its nearly two-hour runtime. Starring Yeoh like her discovery Character of Philippa Georgiou – Former Emperor of a trip‘s Alternate mirror universere-examined and partially recovered during her time on the show before being sent off into unknown times to live a new life – the film follows Georgiou as she is forced to cross paths with the titular agents. A black ops spy organization It was first introduced in Deep Space NineShe was offered a place on a dangerous mission outside the confines of Federation space and with ties to her bloody past.

This team consists of an eclectic mix of characters – led by Alok (Omri Hardwick); Right hand and strong arm, wearing Zev (Rob Kaczynski); Team shape-shifting genius Quasi (Sam Richardson); Deltan agent Millie (Humberly Gonzalez); Wild Card Fuzz (Sven Ruygrok); Overseeing Starfleet is Rachel Garrett (Casey Rohl, playing a younger version of Captain Tricia O’Neill. project-C of The next generation“Yesterday’s Project”) who, along with Yoh, spends the next few hours running, shooting, and sneaking through a galaxy-threatening conspiracy. This is really the vibe Article 31: It’s a little less James Bond, a little more Guardians of the Galaxy, If anything the last series forgot to maintain any sense of honesty that underpins its bizarre humour. This might be fine, if it weren’t for that Star Trek Movie titled Article 31– And it is, so it’s not good, and we’ll look into why later. But K Star Trek Movie titled Article 31he trades any curiosity about his world and The organization named after her to instead cloak itself in a cool but ultimately hollow sci-fi aesthetic.

Article 31 He desperately wants to impress upon his audience that his heroes are great, that what they do is great, and even that the way they all act is atypical of what we expect of them Star Trek Heroes, they’re even more awesome for being so. Garrett, as the only official Starfleet officer among them, has to cross this line from the faltering team – “Starfleet is here to make sure no one commits… killing“, appears in its introductory scene — while also seeming eccentric enough to be one of the gang, which symbolizes one of the film’s fundamental failings. It’s so concerned, even desperate, with conveying its strange accent that it forgets to ask anything interesting about its premise , or the loaded intention behind its title as a film about Section 31 and its place in Star Trekuniverse.

The film doesn’t interact with him once Controversial legacy From Article 31 BC Star Trek History, as it never shows its heroes walking the kind of moral line that would make them anything other than unabashed heroes: the most the audience is given to point out is that this is an unlicensed entity by design is merely that the team’s mission is Outside the boundaries of union space, as it were Star Trek She had never sent her ordinary heroes across the border countless times before. Article 31 He acts as if all of this is bold and new for the franchise, while at the same time ignoring the reality of what could have made it at least interesting: examining what the people who live and breathe Section 31 actually think about the organization and its place within the Federation, and what the cost of defending A utopia of the destruction that would be imposed on someone so willing to bend those ideals.

if Star Trek It’s a series that prides itself on thinking big ideas and asking big questions. Article 31 Obsessed with the little things, because it’s easier to make a cruel joke than to reckon with the complex ideas behind the namesake that the series has explored in the past. All of this may sound like a sting Article 31 For being a movie it’s not, and probably never will be, but it reflects the lack of curiosity I felt throughout the movie. The film’s characters are threadbare beyond being presented as quirky and fun on the surface level – no matter how good the supporting cast is, who are anchored by a fun, but similarly underpowered performance by Michelle Yeoh, as Georgiou gets the bulk of the film’s character work. . It presents a series of espionage tropes, from betrayals to subterfuge and interrogation, but in a way that’s not about actually playing with those tropes Star TrekThe film’s settings and more simply to point out while distinguishing themselves from them, and the film’s pacing is awkward and jarring, moving from one moment to the next quickly enough that it never lets the film sit with its characters or plot stakes for anything meaningful. Let’s say.

This lack of curiosity might be at least forgivable Article 31 It was at least a good action movie, but unfortunately it falters there too. The array of action sequences throughout the film have some interesting ideas, and yes, Yeoh has fun with all of them – there are high kicks galore, even as some of them drag on a little longer than is necessarily welcome. But those interesting ideas are often undermined by lackluster cinematography and editing that often obscures the impact of the action, leaving them hollow.

All of this means that this is not the case Article 31 To be different from what is expected of him Star TrekAnd therefore bad because of that. Instead, it’s just a film that struggles to convey any sort of meaningful identity for itself, all while ignoring the identity it could establish with the broader scope. Star Trek Franchise, regardless of whether or not it ultimately contradicts or resembles it. Perhaps a film that comes in at just under two hours shouldn’t seem like such a slog, however Article 31 No, with no spectacle to wow audiences away from its vulnerable character, nor objective meat on its bones for them to sit and chew. Instead, beneath its deep weirdness, the only thing lurking in the shadows here isn’t a secret, morally compromised spy group: it’s just a very boring movie going on there instead.

Star Trek: Section 31 It begins streaming on Paramount+ on Friday, January 24.

Want more io9 news? Check when to expect the latest marvel, star warsand Star Trek Releases, what’s next for DC Universe in film and televisionAnd everything you want to know about the future Doctor Who.