by Joshua Tyler
| to update
When Urson Scott card Enda game Handfare in 1985, it was not just another scientific novel. It has become a phenomenon, winner of Hugo and Nebula Awards, one of the most influential works in modern speculative imagination.
The story of Andrew “Andrew” was not the genius of a child who was trained to lead the humanitarian war against deadly strange species, only about foreigners or battle tactics. The complex psychological and moral dilemmas of war, youth manipulation, and the destructive consequences of sacrifice have been explored. Book lovers can only dream of seeing life on the big screen.
When adapting the movie to Enda game He finally arrived in 2013, what was supposed to be the beginning of a concession that turned into a disappointing imbalance. It should have been a victory for science fiction, but instead, he failed to make a permanent impact on critics and masses.
That is why Enda game to fail.
Meet the high expectations of classicism
For years, Enda game It was considered “inaccurable”. The novel is filled with internal conflict and deep philosophical topics, many of which happen in the minds of the young novel, Ender. In essence, the story revolves around the extent that one should go to seek victory, especially when this victory is achieved through manipulation and deception.
The focus of the novel on the psychological aspects of war, leadership and morals made it a difficult proposal for Hollywood. As the author Orson Scott Card himself said, the entire story takes place in Eder, which made it difficult to translate into a way that relies heavily on the novel of visual stories.
By the beginning of the first decade of the twentieth century, the appetite for science fiction modifications and the success of films such as Hunger games and Varying This means Enda game She had an opportunity to find an audience. In 2008, the novel’s rights were purchased by Oddlot Entertainment, and production was determined.
Gavin Hood, Director criminalThe Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film, was appointed to the guidance. Unfortunately, Gavin Hood was also director X-MEN origins: WolfirinA movie that is considered one of the worst films of superheroes in all ages.
Hood and a team of the book was adapted to Hood, where Hood also played an important role as a product. The film was green with a budget of $ 110 million, and the studio put its attention on creating a new concession.
A team should have been working
crew Enda game It was stacked with both the emerging stars and the old warriors, including ASA butterfield (Ender Wiggin), Harrison Ford (COLONEL GRAFF), Viola Davis (Major Anderson), Ben Kingsley (Mazer Rackham), Hayley Steinfield (Petra Arkanian), and Ebigl Valentine. It looked like a victory.
Asa Batterfield, who already admired Hugo (2011), it was a strong choice to bring Ander to life. Harrison Ford, a great icon, was well thrown as a hard military commander Colonel Graf. And Ibn Kingsley, who was not alien to play complex roles, on the mysterious mazer rakham.
Despite the relevant talent, the same offers have not completely landed the way they need it. Asa Battlefield’s photography of Edand was solid, but the character was lacked the emotional depth and harsh intelligence that made Ender very convincing in the novel.
While the Petfield photography seized the weakness and youth of Endar, he did not do enough to transfer his internal struggle and the cold logic that supports the decision -making process. This lack of depth Enda made a less sympathetic personality, and this is a decisive defect in a movie that is supposed to be about the cost of sacrifice.
Colonel Graf from Harrison Ford was the most performance in the movie. Ford has always been excellent in playing angry characters with hidden moral ambiguity, and his performance was not an exception. However, Ford’s talent was unable to fully upload the film, which was undermined through a text that failed to highlight the complexity of GRAFF as guides and manipulation.
The difference in conspiracy
Film version of Enda game It remains reasonably loyal to the basic scheme of the novel. However, the differences in the tone, speed and emotional content were important enough to stop the book fans and leave the informal cinema pioneers cold.
The basic hypothesis is the same: Wiggin Young Ender is recruited in a military academy, where it is increasingly trained in a difficult simulation, which ultimately leads to the final battle against Formic Foreigners. Along the way, Ender faces harsh guides, personal isolation, and moral dilemmas as it rises through the ranks.
The most important difference between the novel and the film is the depiction of Enda’s cruelty. In the book, Ender is a strategic expert that uses extremist methods to secure victory. It is emotionally cool, ready to sacrifice anything, including its humanity, to ensure that the human race remains. This makes his awareness in the end of what he did more tragic.
The film is blessed by Ender. Its decisions are framed less as calculated actions of cold logic and more than errors or accidents. This transformation in the description has removed a lot of complexity that made the book very strong.
The film also drops an important subcategi from the book: The complete exploration of Ander’s relationship with his brother Peter, his sister, Valentine. These relationships were essential in the development of Ender in the novel, with a highlight of the emotional cost of his isolation and his struggle with his violent inclinations. In the film, these relationships are barely explored, and while Abitil Prisonen does a good job like Valentine’s Day, the emotional risks of Endar’s personal life have been reduced significantly.
Hurry through good parts
Production values Enda game It was of the first degree, with elegant views, future groups, and special impressive effects. The film was a great look, and the heavy battle sequence in CGI, including training sessions, was visually amazing. It may have been more living, but the appearance of the movie works well.
However, the film has hurt her ability to present the emotional depth required for such a complex story. While the book takes its time in building the Ander’s character, exploring his ideas, motives and moral dilemmas, the film rushes during the main moments.
It was possible to use the time spent in battle simulations and training montage to explore the emotional and philosophical foundations of Ender’s actions. Instead, the audience is left with a series of separate and upset scenes that fail to present the bowel campaign that makes the novel very convincing.
Ender game failed to release
Despite the lineage of the book, the talented actors, the high production values, Enda game Performed at the box office. The film has achieved about $ 125 million worldwide, hardly covers its budget of $ 110 million. Looking at expectations for a great concession, this was a great disappointment. The film has struggled to attract the audience’s attention in a crowded market for 2013.
Critics were divided, where the film sits 62 % on approval Spoiled tomatoes And ranked 6.6/10 a little better on IMDB. While some praised the views and performances, many felt that the film failed to raise the level of the complexity and depth of the source matter. The mitigating photography and the lack of emotional participation were frequent criticism.
Why did Ender failed
Over the years, Enda game I gained small followers, especially among the lovers of the book. Film availability Running The services gave her a new life, but she did not generate creative cultural influence who were hoping for it. The desire to obtain a privilege has never been fulfilled, and the film is still a curiosity in the world of science fiction modifications.
Enda game She failed because he did not pick up the novel of the heart of Urson Scott. She lost the spirit of the story in her attempt to soften herself. The issues of leadership, sacrifice and ethics of war were there, but they rushed in the past. The film missed his chance to echo with the fans the way the novel did, and as a result, Enda game Another example of a great book has not been well translated into the screen.
Source link
https://www.giantfreakinrobot.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/image-87.png