Is it possible to release the Manendez brothers from imprisonment after monsters?

Eric and Liel MindezThe murder case had returned to the spotlight Ryan Murphy‘s Monsters – Now they can walk free after years behind bars.

The parents of the Mindez brothers, Jose and Kitty MinendesHe was found dead in their house in Beverly Hills in 1989. After he called Lille the police, they discovered that Jose had shot him six times and was wounded by Kitty 10 times. Lyle and Erik were not at first as dominant people but were arrested after one year after the processor recorded their sessions Where they confessed to death.

During their prominent trial, the brothers, Jose and Kitty, accused the alleged physical, emotional and sexual assault, Eric and Lille, for the first -class killing and sentenced to life imprisonment without the conditional release in 1996.

Rings Law and order, the new BEL-Air Prince and Soprano Mention the case in the nineties. Brother Mainndes It was also indicated several times On FX drama The People V. OJ Simpson: American Crime Story In 2016, which was produced by Murphy. (In addition to MonstersMurphy also participates in the American story concession.)

On the thirty -fifth anniversary of the death of Jose and Kitty, NBC released eight episodes in 2017, entitled “Battle” Law and System: A real crime – MINDES murders. Quoty I took the case for season 2 to MonstersWho starred Nicholas Chavez and Cooper Koch As Lille and Eric, respectively. After the limited chain occupied the headlines, the support of the Menéndez brothers returned amid their attempts to resume their punishment.

The Office of the Prosecutor in Los Angeles in October 2024 recommended that the IRIC and Lile penalty be reduced due to new evidence indicating that their father claims to harass them. Once Nathan Hoshman It took more than one month, however, the recommendation was left in the air. The judge officially resented in May 2025 to 50 years, making them eligible for a conditional release.

Continue to pass to the collapse of their appeal efforts over the years:

What was the original Eric and Lill camel?

Lael and Eric were arrested in 1990 with two charges of first -class killing for each. Three years later, the brothers were tried separately because they claimed that years of physical, emotional and sexual assault caused fire to them and the father.

The case ended in a trial after the jury was unable to reach a unanimous decision. Re -trial began in 1995, but most of the evidence surrounding abuse cannot be used as a defense. Eric Wali – who were now war together – Ultimately, I was convicted of first -class death. Persons circulated between life without conditional release or the death penalty before choosing the first in 1996.

After he initially stayed in the same prison, Eric and Lille was transferred after the sentence was issued. Lille was transferred to Molim Cret State Prison, while Eric moved from Volsum Prison to Plezant Valley State Prison.

They did not reunite them in 2018 when they were transferred to the Housing Unit itself at the Richard J. Correctional Donovan. That was the first to reunite them since they started spending their sentences almost two decades ago.

How many appeal attempts have occurred?

The California Court of Appeal upheld the killings of Lael and Eric in 1998 and the California Supreme Court refused to review the case later in the same year. Both Manendez Prothes submitted petitions to the California Supreme Court in 1999, which were rejected. They submitted the same petitions in the local United States court and this was rejected in 2003.

The defense team in Eric and at night decided to appeal to the United States Appeal Court for the ninth district, which led to another denial in 2005.

What inspired the last request to be tried?

In 2023, Peacock released an interview entitled Menéndez + What: Boys BaniWhere the singer Roy Rosalon He claimed that he was raped and raped when he was teenage by Eric and Lil’s father, Jose. The accusations were included from the former Menudo member of the seam submitted to the Los Angeles County Supreme Court.

The court documents requested the re -trial during the martyrdom of new evidence in the case, such as Rossilo’s allegations against Jose and a recent discovered message. Eric wrote to his cousin Andy Kano a description Sexual assault on his father Months of murders.

“No one looked at the effects of (cousin) until 2015, when it was found, 10 years after our recent attractiveness,” Eric and Leila’s lawyer after the conviction Mark Geragos He said in a statement to the people In September 2024. “We say that the second trial did not correspond to the constitutional protection for various reasons. And for the rhetoric (Corbus’ petition) has new evidence. It requires new evidence because this issue was mainly for 17 years.”

Gerargos collapsed Three possible results From the request.

“The judge can deny this, the judge can order Da to respond, or the judge can do what he did, and who was issuing an order to respond to Da to respond informally, which they took seriously over the past 15 months because we have provided evidence for them.” (We submitted data from 24 family members who) all of us asked to resent, and they presented a number of other documents and evidence for them to look at them and consider them while making a decision. “

What is the current update for a re -trial request?

A spokesman for the Los Angeles County Lawyer’s Office issued a statement on how the office has fulfilled the claims made in the petition.

“The issue is awaiting an informal response, which is currently scheduled for September 26, 2024,” the provincial prosecutor said. the people.

In the same month, Netflix announced that Lael and Erik It was interviewed with Brother Mainndes Documentary film. The private, which will be released in October 2024, includes footage of conversations with the jury Betty OldfieldKitty sister Joan Vander Moulin And the public prosecutor Pamela Bozanic.

“Everyone asks why we killed our parents,” said Lyle in the trailer. “Perhaps people can now understand the truth.”

Eric added: “What happened on that night is well known, but it was not told much … So we were not the ones who saw the story about our lives. Two children do not commit this crime for money.”

Eric gave a new hearing for their judgment one month after the Prosecutor’s Office in Los Angeles County was martyred with new evidence indicating that their father claims that they were harassing them. The Office of the Prosecutor in Los Angeles in October 2024 recommended that the camels of Eric and Layl be reduced.

Hoshman walked into this when he became the next boycott lawyer. In March 2025, Hochman’s office withdraws its request to reduce the rulings based on the brotherhood who claims that they did not show a full look at their crimes. Erik and Lil were still dissatisfied two months to 50 years, which could make them eligible for the conditional release after this process passed.